Companies offer wellness programs because leaders and employees see the benefits of promoting physical, mental, social, and financial fitness. However, sometimes, companies can get too heavy-handed in their promotion of better health.

Case in point: Yale University was hit with a class-action lawsuit for the structure of its employee wellness program, Health Expectations. Like most wellness programs, Yale offers incentives to participants for certain activities, such as getting an annual checkup or specific medical screening.

The program is described as voluntary for the university's 5,000 union workers, but employees who don't participate are charged $25 a week, the equivalent of $1,300 per year.

The plaintiffs, who are represented by the AARP Foundation, said the program is not voluntary if it includes punishment for non-participation. Given the size of the penalty and the average compensation for many of the union employees, the “voluntary” program is mandatory for all intents and purposes. Employees explained that to participate in the program, they must agree that information from the medical exams, personal health information, and family history could be shared with multiple wellness vendors.  Workers also said that forcing them to divulge personal health information could lead to discrimination, conflicting with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA), federal laws that protect employee privacy.

 

Wellness Incentives Are Common

It's not unheard of for organizations like Yale to offer an incentive to employees for participating in a wellness program. A study by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that 50% of large companies offered biometric screening for employees, and among those, 60% offered an incentive for participating, such as a reduced premium contribution or cash. The problem comes when companies offer a disincentive or penalty for not taking part in the program. figure-12-110

 

New EEOC Rules Add Complexity

Before 2019, employers could provide financial incentives for employees in wellness programs as long as participation was "voluntary" and the incentive was not more than 30% of the total cost of the employee's health plan. In January of this year, however, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) vacated the 30% limit and has not yet issued new guidelines. As a result, employers are not sure what kind of financial incentives companies can provide or what constitutes voluntary participation.

 

Alternatives For Screening Incentives

While the law is in limbo, employers still want to encourage wellness program participation. Incentives can and should be used to motivate employees to focus on well-being, and many companies allow employees to accumulate points that lead up to rewards.

If companies want to offer incentives for clinical exams, such as biometric screening or health assessments (although there are compelling reasons not to provide these exams), they can continue with this practice without getting into legal trouble if they also offer non-clinical alternatives.

Wellness expert Al Lewis describes how this works on a Whiteboard Wednesday session. He gives this example: if an employee can accumulate 100 points by participating in clinical assessments, companies should also offer several non-clinical programs employees can participate instead, such as Wellable, fitness tracking, and step challenges. The key is that the non-clinical options must add up to the 100 as well, so the employee has an equal opportunity to meet the incentive without being forced to share their personal health information.

The Yale University lawsuit hasn't been settled, but companies should examine the structure of their wellness programs and look at alternatives to "mandatory" clinical screenings to stay out of murky waters.

Get our stories delivered From us to your inbox weekly.

The Workplace Is An Opportunity For Health Promotion

Only about 20% of American adults over the age of 18 get the recommended amount of physical...

Continuous Wellness Challenge Best Practices

This is the topic of our next webinar: Launching A Continuous Incentive Wellness Challenge. Sign up...

7 Core Metrics To Measure An Employee Health Coaching Initiative

This is an excerpt from our latest eBook: Employee Health Coaching 101 - Everything You Need To...

Wellable Research: 2018 Wellness Industry Trends Report

With new advancements in technology, constant regulatory changes, and a tightening labor market,...

Study: Employee Perception Of Wellness Programs Improving

Every year, the Consumer Health Mindset Study explores new and emerging topics related to the...

Employee Wellness Lessons From Amazon's Choice For JV CEO

Last week, Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway, and JPMorgan Chase announced that Dr. Atul Gawande will be...

39% Of Large Employers Offer $151-$500 In Wellness Incentives

Every year, the Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) releases their Employer Health Benefits Survey,...

Mental Health In The Workplace

Established by the World Health Organization (WHO), October 10 is World Mental Health Day.  The...

Pain Management: Another Reason For Sleep Promotion

Pain is cited as the most common reason Americans access the health care system.  It is a leading...

Study: Mental Health Apps Not As Effective As Perceived

As companies expand their employee wellness programs to address mental health, there is increased...

Employee Satisfaction With Health Plans Improving, Still Room To Grow

It’s commonly thought that employees are increasingly dissatisfied with their healthcare plan, but...

Study: Long-Term Gains From Short-Term Exercise Programs

We know that exercise is an excellent way to stay healthy. We also know that regular movement, even...

Caregivers Need Wellness Too

When employers think about wellness benefits, they usually have their employees’ well-being in...

Survey: Workers Conceal Mental Health Issues From Employers

Despite the progress made in destigmatizing mental health issues and pursuing positive emotional...

Community Well-Being Rankings By State (US)

Boston University School of Public Health (BUSPH) and Sharecare released a set of three indices to...

Pulse Check: Oral Health And Employee Well-Being

Every month, Wellable asks a single question to the large, growing, and dedicated community of...

Survey: Employers See Value In Integrated Employee Benefits

Every two years, Anthem publishes their Integrated Health Care Report, which explores how...

Fitbit Study Correlates Heart Rate Variability With Cardiovascular Function

An estimated one in five Americans currently owns a smartwatch of some kind. Many users wear these...

“Retailization” Of Primary Care

Gaining access to the health care services and products one needs can be inconvenient, expensive,...

The Evolution Of Apple Health And The Future Of Personal Wellness Technologies

Personal wellness technologies are increasing the frequency and ease at which individuals and their...