In a draft recommendation statement, the United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF or Task Force) found that the current evidence is inadequate to recommend screening for vitamin D deficiency in asymptomatic adults. The findings are based on a systematic review of 46 studies that assessed various doses, frequency, and duration of treatment with vitamin D to examine the benefits and harms of treatment. The evidence suggests that vitamin D treatment, with or without calcium, had no effect on most health outcomes; for some outcomes, the evidence was limited. Treatment was also found to have no impact on mortality; fractures; incidences of diabetes, cardiovascular disease, or cancer; or depression among community-dwelling populations. Evidence was inconclusive for the effect of treatment on falls. Active treatment and control groups had a similar incidence of total adverse events, serious adverse events, and other harms.

The draft recommendation is now posted for public comment, and after reviewing the comments, the Task Force will deliver a final ruling. When final, this recommendation will replace the 2014 USPSTF recommendation statement, which also concluded that evidence was insufficient to assess the balance of benefits and harms of screening vitamin D deficiency in asymptomatic adults.

Vitamin D is a vital nutrient for bone health and may play a role in other aspects of health as well. Individuals typically receive vitamin D through certain foods, supplements, and sun exposure. It is important to note that since ideal vitamin D levels can vary from person to person, more information is needed to develop a consensus regarding the precise levels of vitamin D required for optimal health. This consensus may impact the assessment of vitamin D screenings.

 

Screenings For Employers

Most employers do not offer vitamin D screenings, so the content of this post may seem out of place. However, it is important for employers to be aware of the guidance the USPSTF offers because many of them have non-recommended services as part of their employee wellness programs. For example, many employers encourage all employees to receive an annual physical or biometric screening despite this procedure not being a recommended service by the USPSTF for asymptomatic adults of a certain age. Some employers encourage other preventive screenings and procedures that are also not recommended. These result in poor employee wellness programs that do not achieve the results employers are seeking.

The Task Force does not consider the costs of a preventive service when determining a recommendation grade. This means that preventive screenings like annual physicals or biometric screenings are not seen as valuable even when costs are not taken into consideration. When employers, who view their wellness program as an investment, evaluate the value of their programs, the case for non-recommended services becomes even weaker, further bolstering the argument that employers need to quit offering these types of services.

 

About USPSTF

The USPSTF is an independent, volunteer panel of national experts in prevention and evidence-based medicine. The Task Force works to improve the health of all Americans by making evidence-based recommendations about clinical preventive services such as screenings, counseling services, and preventive medications.

Get our stories delivered From us to your inbox weekly.

CDC Study: BMI Is Incorrect Indicator For 18% Of The U.S.

A recent New York Times article provides specific numbers about the accuracy of a controversial...

Survey: 65% Of Millennials Think Fitness Tracking Is Important

According to a survey commissioned by Technogym, 65% of millennials think fitness tracking is...

IRS: Cash Rewards For Wellness Program Participation Are Taxable

According to an advice memorandum released on May 27 by the United States Internal Revenue Service...

Study: “Enhanced” Walking Programs Deliver Results

According to a new study from Independence Blue Cross, “enhanced” walking programs encouraged...

Study Evaluates Fitness Trackers, Communication, And Health Promotion

There is no shortage of studies assessing the ability of fitness trackers to promote physical...

Apple Watch = Sustained New Year’s Resolution?

As mid-February approaches, the magic of New Year’s Resolutions is starting to wear off; the...

Study: Active Workstations Enhance Cognitive Functions, Improve Memory

As the popularity of standing desks increases in corporate offices, treadmill and elliptical desks...

Study: Top Performers Are Three Times As Valuable As Other Peers

The term “top performers” is self-explanatory; it indicates people who outperform their peers in...

Study: Standing Desks May Have Negative Effects

Standing desks continue to receive praise for their ability to improve the health and productivity...

Wellness, Perks Comprise Trending Benefit List

According to a list from Employee Benefit News on 15 trending workplace benefits, employee wellness...

5 Scientifically Proven Health Benefits Of Gratitude

For those readers in the United States, tomorrow will be Thanksgiving, and to some, the official...

USPSTF All Adults Should Be Screened For Excessive Alcohol Use

United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) is "an independent panel of experts in...

Study: iPhone Step Tracking Accurate, Distance Not So Much

Although wearable devices offer a number of benefits, cost often makes them prohibitive for...

Study: Workplace Yoga Lowers Employee Stress

Yoga has long been considered an effective way to decrease stress in general, but few studies have...

USPTF: All Adults Should Be Screened For Illegal Drugs

Illegal drug use in the United States is on the rise. To address this growing problem, the U.S....

Survey: Millennials More Likely To Turn To Online Health Education Than Visit Doctors

A recent survey by Harmony Healthcare IT of more than 2,000 people aged 23 to 38 revealed that...

U-Haul Will Implement New Nicotine-Free Hiring Policy

Phoenix-based moving company U-Haul recently announced that it would cease hiring smokers and...

USPSTF Recommends Hypertension Screening for All Adults

Hypertension is one of the most common physical health issues today. According to the Centers for...

Say Hello To Halo, Amazon’s New Wearable Device

Despite the challenges many wearable device companies have experienced over the past several years,...

Robot Therapists

Since the creation of the Turing Test in the 1950s, researchers and inventors have been trying to...