Request Demo
Request Demo

Last week, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) filed a lawsuit against Honeywell, and this isn’t the first.  The EEOC claims Honeywell required its employees and their spouses to "submit to medical tests or risk being penalized up to $4,000.”  The commission says the penalties violate both the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA).  Under the ADA, such medical testing is meant to be voluntary, and GINA bans employees from "offering inducements" to obtain family medical histories.

Since the lawsuit was filed, numerous entities, including wellness vendors who make their living on biometric screenings, have come to the defense of Honeywell.  A major milestone in the case happened yesterday when the U.S. district judge in Minneapolis denied the EEOC’s request to block Honeywell’s wellness program.  The case will continue in court and Honeywell will continue with their program in the meantime.

LawsuitThe problem with this analysis is the focus on the legal right.  We aren’t legal experts and don’t want to weigh in on what is legal or not.  Rather, we created Wellable to empower people to live healthier and happier lives while providing financial benefits to the person (employee) and their health plan sponsor (employer).  The question, in our mind, is not an issue of legal right.  Rather, it is a question of whether or not Honeywell is furthering their strategic objectives by implementing such a program.

  • Are employees participating in the program because they want to improve their health or because of the penalty?
  • Is Honeywell creating a program that is attracting and retaining high quality employees?
  • Win or lose, is the publicity of the lawsuit good for business?

Honeywell’s response was telling: “The incentives we provide are specifically sanctioned by two separate federal statutes – the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the ACA. Honeywell’s wellness plan incentives are in strict compliance with both HIPAA and the ACA’s guidelines, which were designed by Congress to encourage healthier lifestyles while helping to control healthcare costs.”  Based on their response, it sounds like Honeywell’s sole motivation was to save money rather than improve the health and livelihood of their employees.  Even if the program is successful at containing costs, do most employers believe this is the way to build a successful business?

Wellable believes in putting people first and that wellness is something employers should do for their employees, not to them.  The best way to have a successful program is to achieve these objectives simultaneously:

  • Employees appreciate the program and want to participate (you can measure this by engagement)
  • Employers realize cost savings, improved productivity, and a happier, more satisfied workforce
  • Outsiders of your organization view your program as a benefit and associate your company with a positive image (this helps with recruitment, brand equity, and much more)

Honeywell should build a program for their employees by thinking about what is best for their employees.  If they put people first, the legal woes will go away as well.

Get our latest articles delivered straight to your inbox!

Biden Administration Sets Deadline For Company Vaccine Mandate

Although the measure was first announced in September, the details of the requirement for large US...

FDA Approves The Marketing Of Three E-Cigarettes

An e-cigarette is an electronic device that allows users to inhale a vapor containing nicotine (the...

Should Employers Continue Screening Workers For Marijuana Use?

In recent years, an increasing number of employers have ditched marijuana drug testing. Their...

President Biden’s Updated COVID-19 Decrees – What Employers Should Know

In his speech last Thursday, September 9th, President Biden laid out his administration's updated...

Employers Respond To FDA Approval Of COVID-19 Vaccine

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has granted full approval to Pfizer-BioNTech’s COVID-19...

CDC Guidance Released As Millions Of Adults Receive COVID-19 Vaccine

On March 8, the CDC released its first set of guidance for adults that have received the COVID-19...

Biden Administration Calls On Employers To Support COVID-19 Vaccination Efforts

Last month, the White House COVID Response Team gave a press briefing on the current state of the...

EEOC Issues Proposed Wellness Incentive Rules, Impacting Workplace Wellness Programs

This blog was written by a guest contributor, Barbara Zabawa, President of the Center for Health...

Experts Explain Details Surrounding Proposed EEOC Rule Changes

Following years of anticipation, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is finally...

With Reopening Plans Underway, Employers Shouldn’t Leave Out Benefits Changes

In May, due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on business operations, the IRS issued a notice...